England in India

Sanjay Manjeraker here is one of the lone sane voices in the controversy surrounding Harbhajan Singh's axing from the Indian side for the first 2 ODI's against England. For just how much longer is Indian cricket going to base their selection policy on reputations? Harbhajan's record over the last few years has been distinctly average and it's about time somebody else was given a fair crack. Going back to domestic cricket could also be a blessing in disguise for Harbhajan, for if he is good enough, then he will earn his way back into the side through the weight of performances. 

The other cricketer in the news for being dropped is Ashish Nehra. His outburst at being ignored was uncalled for. It's another decision that made sense to me as Nehra's lack of fitness coupled with his inability to field or bat has for long made him a risky proposition. Indian cricket can only move forward if it accepts the fact that change can no longer be avoided. 

Vinay Kumar, however, is not the answer. The Karnataka medium pacer may have a decent first-class record, but has struggled at the international level. He is another example of the 'typical' Indian seamer - bowls in the mid 120's and tries to maintain a decent line and length. Unfortunately, he neither has the pace nor the accuracy required to trouble quality batsman. 

Despite playing at home, IMHO, India will not start as favorites. India remain a side ravaged by injuries and they are up against a decent English side who will sense that this may be their best opportunity to get one over India at home. England will come hard at India and it remains to be seen whether the youngsters in the Indian side can handle the heat. 

Shoaib Akhtar's Book

Shoaib Akhtar has as usual been in the news for all the wrong reasons. His recently launched autobiography has attracted the ire of the BCCI as it contains some criticism directed against Sachin Tendulkar. If publicity was the objective, Shoaib has ensured that he got it in adequate measure.  The BCCI's reaction though has as usual been extremely over the top. Shoaib just like everybody else is entitled to his opinion and it is ridiculous to ask him to apologize for expressing his views.